Best Pie Dish 2026: 8 Top Glass, Ceramic and Metal Picks

Quick answer

The best pie dish for most home bakers is the Pyrex 9.5-inch Fluted Rim Glass Pie Plate: it is oven-safe to 500°F and lets you see when the bottom crust is golden. For a heirloom ceramic dish, choose Emile Henry’s 9-inch Pie Dish, made in France. For the crispiest crust, choose the USA Pan aluminized steel pie pans.

Below we compare eight pie dishes and pie pans in glass, ceramic, stoneware and metal, explain the best pie dish material for each kind of pie, and cover the best pie dish for quiche and deep-dish Thanksgiving pies.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability change often, so check Amazon for the current price. Learn more.

Top 3 picks

Best pie dish overall

Pyrex 9.5-inch Fluted Rim Glass Pie Plate: a classic glass pie plate, oven-safe up to 500°F, made in the USA per the listing, that also works for reheating and serving.

Check current price on Amazon →

Best ceramic splurge

Emile Henry Made in France 9-Inch Pie Dish: high-fired Burgundy clay, oven-safe to 520°F and able to go from freezer or fridge to a hot oven, per the brand.

Check current price on Amazon →

Best pie pan for crispy crust

USA Pan Aluminized Steel Pie Pan, Set of 2: commercial-grade, heavy-gauge aluminized steel with a corrugated surface and PTFE-free silicone nonstick coating, made in the USA.

Check current price on Amazon →

Best pie dish for Thanksgiving: a golden apple pie with leaf-shaped crust in a white ceramic pie dish

The right pie dish is the difference between a crisp, golden bottom crust and a pale, soggy one. Material, depth and rim shape all change how a pie bakes, and Thanksgiving week is when most of us find out our old dish is too shallow or chipped.

We compared eight pie dishes and pie pans from Pyrex, Emile Henry, USA Pan, Le Creuset, MORA, MALACASA, LE TAUCI and GoodCook. Every detail comes from the Amazon listings; when a listing is silent, we say “not stated.”

Best pie dish comparison table

This best pie dish table compares material, size, max oven temperature and dishwasher care, all from the listings. On a phone, swipe sideways.

Pie dish	Material	Size	Max oven temp	Dishwasher	Tier	Link
Pyrex 9.5″ Fluted Glass	Glass	9.5 in	500°F	Hand wash (per listing)	Budget-friendly	See it on Amazon
Emile Henry 9″ Pie Dish	Burgundy clay ceramic	9 in	520°F	Yes	Premium	See it on Amazon
USA Pan Pie Pan, 2-pk	Aluminized steel, nonstick	9 in (baking surface)	Not stated	Not stated	Mid-range	See it on Amazon
Le Creuset Heritage Fluted	Stoneware	9 in	500°F (-9°F to 500°F)	Not stated	Premium	See it on Amazon
MORA Deep Fluted	Ceramic	9 in wide, 2.5 in deep (inside)	Not stated in bullets	Not stated in bullets	Mid-range	See it on Amazon
MALACASA Fluted	Ceramic	9 in	Not stated	Yes	Budget-friendly	See it on Amazon
LE TAUCI Ceramic, 2-pk	Porcelain	9 in, 1.7 in tall	482°F	Yes	Budget-friendly	See it on Amazon
GoodCook Everyday	Steel, nonstick	9 in	Not stated	Not stated	Budget-friendly	See it on Amazon

The 8 best pie dishes and pie pans

1. Pyrex C-209 9.5-Inch Fluted Rim Glass Pie Plate: Best Overall

Best Overall

Glass is the most forgiving pie dish material for home bakers because you can lift the plate and check the underside. That is why this Pyrex is our best pie dish overall: a 9.5-inch plate with a fluted rim for crimping, oven-safe up to 500°F, made in the USA per the listing title.

It also doubles for reheating and serving, so the same plate can go from the oven to the Thanksgiving dessert table. The 9.5-inch size suits most standard pie recipes.

Good to know: Ships from Amazon, sold by AMCAN. The listing says hand washable. Like any glass bakeware, avoid sudden temperature changes such as a hot dish on a wet counter.

Best for: First-time pie bakers, pumpkin and custard pies, anyone who wants to see the bottom crust

Check current price on Amazon → Add to Amazon cart (save it for Black Friday) →

2. Emile Henry Made in France 9-Inch Pie Dish: Best Ceramic Splurge

Best Ceramic Splurge

Emile Henry has made ceramics in France since 1850, and this is the dish to buy once and keep. It is made of high-fired Burgundy clay (the brand’s HR high-resistance ceramic) with even heat diffusion and strong heat retention, so pies stay warm on the table longer.

The brand says it can go straight from freezer or refrigerator to a hot oven, is oven-safe to 520°F, and is also broiler, microwave and dishwasher safe. The hard glaze resists scratches and crazing, and the fluted sides help you form an even crust.

Good to know: Shipped and sold by Amazon.com. The title says White, while one bullet mentions Nougat, so check the color shown before ordering.

Best for: A heirloom gift, quiche and savory pies, bakers who want a dish that looks good on the table

Check current price on Amazon → Add to Amazon cart (save it for Black Friday) →

3. USA Pan Bakeware Aluminized Steel Pie Pan, Set of 2: Best Pie Pan for Crispy Crust

Best Pie Pan for Crispy Crust

Metal heats faster than glass or ceramic, which is why bakers who chase a flaky, deep-golden crust often choose it. This is our best pie pan for crispy crust: two 9-inch pans in commercial-grade, heavy-gauge aluminized steel with a corrugated surface that USA Pan says helps air circulate for even baking and quick release.

The nonstick Americoat coating is a silicone coating that the brand says is PTFE, PFOA and BPA free. The baking surface is 9 x 9 x 1.5 inches; outer size is 10 x 10 x 1.5 inches. Made in the USA from globally sourced materials.

Good to know: Set of 2. Shipped and sold by Amazon.com. Oven max and dishwasher care are not stated in the bullets.

Best for: Blind-baking crusts, fruit pies with a lattice, baking two pies at once

Check current price on Amazon → Add to Amazon cart (save it for Black Friday) →

4. Le Creuset Stoneware Heritage Fluted Pie Dish: Best Hostess Gift

Best Hostess Gift

Le Creuset’s Heritage pie dish is the one people recognize, which makes it a strong hostess gift for Thanksgiving. The stoneware is made for even heat distribution with no hot spots and keeps food warm or cold for serving.

The colorful glaze is nonporous, non-reactive, scratch-resistant and resists stains and flavor absorption. Le Creuset lists thermal resistance from -9°F to 500°F, and the smooth enamel interior releases food easily and resists cracking and crazing.

Good to know: 9 inches, White (other colors such as Cerise are listed). Shipped and sold by Amazon.com.

Best for: Host and hostess gifts, Le Creuset collectors, serving pies at the table

Check current price on Amazon →

5. MORA Ceramic Deep Fluted Pie Pan: Best Deep-Dish

Best Deep-Dish

If your family wants a tall apple pie, depth matters. MORA measures 9 inches wide and 2.5 inches deep inside, with fluted sides for easy, pretty edges, and the brand says it fits any standard pie recipe.

MORA says it uses Paladin Clay that is 20% stronger than competitors (the brand’s claim) with good heat retention to keep food hot longer. The modern farmhouse look suits a holiday table.

Good to know: Ships from Amazon, sold by Mora Ceramics. Oven max and dishwasher details are not in the bullets we read.

Best for: Deep-dish apple pie, pot pies, a farmhouse-style kitchen

Check current price on Amazon →

6. MALACASA Ceramic Fluted Pie Pan: Best Pie Dish for Quiche

Best Pie Dish for Quiche

This is our best pie dish for quiche on a budget. The 9-inch ceramic plate has a fluted edge for grip and tall, thick sidewalls that MALACASA says help crusts bake evenly. The brand says it resists staining, cracking and odors.

It is microwave, oven, freezer and dishwasher safe, and the listing says it can go from freezer or refrigerator straight into a hot oven, so you can bake a make-ahead quiche and serve it in the same dish.

Good to know: Ships from Amazon, sold by MALACASA. The title says 40 oz while a bullet says 36 oz, so treat the capacity as about 36 to 40 oz.

Best for: Quiche, savory tarts, brunch hosts

Check current price on Amazon →

7. LE TAUCI Ceramic Pie Pans, Set of 2: Best Value Set

Best Value Set

LE TAUCI gives you two 9-inch porcelain pie dishes, each 1.7 inches tall and 36 oz, so you can bake pumpkin and pecan at the same time. The listing says they also fit a store-bought 9-inch pie crust.

The wide wave-edge rim helps you crimp dough and grip the dish. They are microwave, oven, freezer and dishwasher safe, with oven use up to 482°F, and the glaze resists food odors and flavors.

Good to know: Set of 2, white. Ships from Amazon, sold by THE GOODIES.

Best for: Two-pie Thanksgivings, store-bought crust shortcuts, gifting one and keeping one

Check current price on Amazon →

8. GoodCook Everyday Nonstick Pie Pan: Best Budget Pie Pan

Best Budget Pie Pan

GoodCook’s 9-inch pan is a simple, budget-friendly metal option. It distributes heat evenly for thorough crust baking, and the scratch-resistant nonstick coating is metal-spatula safe, so you can serve straight from the pan.

The wide rim makes it easy to grab with oven mitts, and the heavy-duty steel is made to resist warping. Outer measurements are 10.8 x 9.7 x 1.5 inches.

Good to know: Gray. Shipped and sold by Amazon.com. Dishwasher care not stated in the bullets.

Best for: A spare pan, potlucks, college or first-apartment kitchens

Check current price on Amazon →

Best pie dish material: glass vs ceramic vs metal

Spreading pumpkin pie filling in a glass pie plate, a classic best pie dish material for checking the bottom crust — Photo: Unsplash

There is no single best pie dish material; each one bakes a little differently. Use this table to match the material to the pie you make most.

Material	How it bakes	Best for	Watch out for
Glass	Heats steadily; you can see the bottom crust	Pumpkin, custard, cream pies, beginners	Sudden temperature changes; can break if dropped
Ceramic / stoneware	Heats slowly, holds heat, bakes evenly	Quiche, deep-dish fruit pies, serving at the table	Bottom crust browns more slowly; heavier
Metal (aluminized steel)	Heats fastest; crispest, most golden crust	Blind-baked shells, fruit pies, lattice tops	Acidic fillings and metal utensils on some coatings
Nonstick steel	Fast heat, easy release	Budget baking, potlucks	Coating wears over time

A simple rule: choose glass if you want to see what is happening, ceramic if you want a pretty dish that holds heat, and metal if you want the crispest crust.

How to choose the best pie pans

Size: most recipes are written for a 9-inch pie plate; 9.5-inch glass plates like Pyrex hold slightly more filling.
Depth: standard dishes are about 1.25 to 1.75 inches deep; deep-dish pans like MORA (2.5 inches inside) suit tall apple pies and pot pies. Add about a quarter more filling for deep dishes.
Rim: a wide or fluted rim makes crimping easier and gives you something to hold with oven mitts.
Oven limit: check the max temperature if you start pies hot (425°F is common) or use the broiler.
Care: dishwasher-safe ceramic is easiest; glass and coated metal often last longer with hand washing.

Pie dish size	Typical use	Crust tip
9 in standard	Most pie recipes	Roll dough to about 12 in
9.5 in	Glass plates, slightly more filling	Roll to about 12.5 to 13 in
9 in deep-dish (2 in+)	Tall fruit pies, pot pies	Roll to about 13 in; extra filling
10 to 10.5 in	Large quiches, family pies	Roll to about 14 in

Best pie pan for crispy crust

For the best pie pan for crispy crust, choose metal. Our pick is the USA Pan aluminized steel set; GoodCook is the budget-friendly alternative. Metal transfers heat faster, so the bottom crust sets before the filling makes it soggy.

Bake on the lowest oven rack, close to the heat.
Preheat a baking sheet and set the pie on it.
Blind-bake the crust (with weights) for wet fillings such as pumpkin or custard.
Brush the bottom crust with egg wash before adding filling.
Let fruit pies cool for a few hours so the juices thicken.

Using glass or ceramic? Add a few minutes to the bake and check the underside of a glass plate for an even golden color.

Best pie dish for quiche

The best pie dish for quiche is ceramic with tall sides: MALACASA is our budget-friendly pick and Emile Henry is the splurge. Ceramic bakes egg custard gently and evenly, and a pretty dish can go straight to the brunch table.

Partly blind-bake the crust so the bottom does not turn soggy.
Fill to just below the rim; egg custard puffs as it bakes.
Bake until the center is just set. FoodSafety.gov lists 160°F as the safe minimum for egg dishes such as quiche in its safe minimum temperature chart.
Rest 10 to 15 minutes before slicing.

Pie dish care and storage

Let glass and ceramic cool before washing, and never put a hot dish on a wet or cold surface.
Soak baked-on filling in warm, soapy water instead of scraping.
Use wooden or silicone tools on nonstick metal unless the listing says metal-safe (GoodCook says it is).
Store pie dishes with a paper towel between them to prevent chips.

Leftover pie? The FDA’s safe food handling basics recommend refrigerating perishable foods promptly, which matters for pumpkin, custard and cream pies.

Thanksgiving baking plan and pie dish gift ideas

Planning several pies? Bake fruit pies one or two days ahead and pumpkin the day before, and keep the oven free for the turkey; our best roasting pan for turkey guide covers the main event. A stand mixer from our best stand mixers roundup makes whipped cream and dough faster, and our host Thanksgiving on a budget guide helps you plan the rest of the meal.

Recipient	Gift	Why it works
Thanksgiving host	Le Creuset Heritage Fluted Pie Dish	Recognizable and pretty on the table; see more luxury hostess gifts
Serious baker	Emile Henry 9″ Pie Dish	Made in France, oven to table
New baker	Pyrex 9.5″ glass plate	Easy to see the crust
Home cook who has everything	USA Pan 2-pack	Upgrade for crisp crusts; more in kitchen gifts for home cooks

Many of these often see holiday deals around Black Friday, so check the current price on Amazon, and check the delivery date shown at checkout if you need a dish before Thanksgiving.

How we chose these pie dishes (not tested)

We did not bake in these pie dishes hands-on. To build this best pie dish list, we read each Amazon product page for material, size, depth, oven limits, care instructions and seller details, and we chose a mix of glass, ceramic, stoneware and metal so there is a good fit for every kind of pie and budget. Where a listing contradicted itself (for example on capacity or color), we said so.

Best pie dish FAQ

What is the best pie dish?

The Pyrex 9.5-inch Fluted Rim Glass Pie Plate is our best pie dish overall because it is oven-safe to 500°F and lets you see the bottom crust. Emile Henry is the best ceramic splurge and USA Pan is best for a crispy crust.

What is the best pie dish material?

The best pie dish material depends on the pie. Glass lets you check browning, ceramic holds heat and suits quiche and serving, and metal gives the crispest crust. Many bakers keep one glass and one metal pan.

What are the best pie pans for a crispy crust?

The best pie pan for crispy crust is metal. USA Pan aluminized steel pie pans heat quickly and have a corrugated surface for even baking. Bake on a low rack on a preheated sheet.

What is the best pie dish for quiche?

A ceramic dish with tall sides is the best pie dish for quiche. MALACASA is our budget-friendly pick and Emile Henry is our splurge. Partly blind-bake the crust first.

Are the best pie pans glass or metal?

Neither is best for everything. Glass is easier for beginners and custard pies; metal bakes crusts faster and crisper. Ceramic sits in between and looks best on the table.